Justice Judith Gische of Supreme Court, New York County presents a primer on attorney fee litigation and the disposition of counterclaims for legal malpractice in Hurley v. Bulah Church of God in Christ Jesus, Inc. In this case the Church had gone through some hard times. A pastor was accused of financial wrongdoing, and
Legal Malpractice News
A Federal Primer in Legal Malpractice
ENGLAND and MIDWEST GEMS, INC., -against- . FELDMAN and FELDMAN LAW GROUP, Defendants.11 Civ. 1396 (CM) UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK; 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 36382; March 28, 2011, is as good a primer in the general and substantive laws of legal malpractice as one might read. …
What Does Plaintiff Have to Prove for Legal Malpractice Case?
Here’s a fairly simple case. Plaintiff signs a real estate contract with a mortgage contingency. If she cannot obtain a mortgage she must give notice. If she properly gives notice she gets her down payment back. She hires attorney who negligently fails to give notice. She does not get her down payment back. Legal malpractice?…
Much Maneuvering but Little Movement in a Legal Malpractice Case
One really can’t tell from the decision, but this appears to be a personal injury – motor vehicle case in NYC with a blown statute. The decision in Greene v Sager 2011 NY Slip Op 50688(U) Decided on April 19, 2011 Supreme Court, Kings County Rivera, J. sets forth the various standards for a summary…
Is There a Secret Statute of Limitations Argument Almost Never Made in Legal Malpractice?
We think there is. It’s hiding inAccess Point Med., LLC v Mandell ;2011 NY Slip Op 30866(U)
April 8, 2011 Supreme Court, New York County Docket Number: 102082/2010
Here is how it goes. Generally in legal malpractice or in breach of fiduciary duty the statute of limitations begins to run on the date…
A Huge Breach of Fiduciary Duty Case, But Too Late
We think that plaintiffs should have been on notice when they were asked to do business with Bill Kidd, but even his name was not a tip-off. Here’s what happened. Kidd invested $5 million to start a low-cost durable medical equipment business that was dependent on getting cheep materials from China. He hired Troutman and…
Minutia Make the Difference in Upstate Divorce-Legal Malpractice Case
How does one prove that the settlement was not good enough, given the circumstances? How does one prove that had this or that taken place, that Husband would have paid less, and more to the point, how does one prove that Husband was the victim rather than the beneficiary of the settlement? It’s all in the…
An Informal Arrangement Leads to Dismissal of Legal Malpractice Case
Win Hay LLC v Chin ; 2011 NY Slip Op 02801 ; Decided on April 7, 2011 ; Appellate Division, First Department is an example of the most informal type of arrangement between an attorney and a client. Client paid the attorney, who "forwarded" the fees to another attorney. This informal type of relationship is unusual…
What They Didn’t Tell Her, Hurt Her in Legal Malpractice
Guayara v Harry I. Katz, P.C. ; 2011 NY Slip Op 02845 ;Decided on April 5, 2011 ;Appellate Division, Second Department is a relatively straightforward legal malpractice case involving multiple defendants. Is a claim that defendants knew of a judgment won by plaintiff and failed to tell her of methods by which she could…
Bad Practice Within Legal Malpractice Litigation
How often do cases explode because of discovery abuses? We do not have a firm answer, but much of the legal malpractice litigation world arises from discovery abuses. Here, in Rock City Sound, Inc. v Bashian & Farber, LLP ;2011 NY Slip Op 02861 ;Decided on April 5, 2011 ;Appellate Division, Second Department we see…