Courts are ready to consider dismissal of legal malpractice cases, especially when the motion for dismissal is predicated on the "but for" portion of the legal malpractice formula. Put another way, even on thinly produced evidence, and before there is any discovery, courts are willing and able to determine whether plaintiff could have succeeded in
Legal Malpractice News
A Puzzling Decision in Legal Malpractice
As the economic times turn around, we are still seeing the results of the mortgage bubble. in Ferreira v Citiwide Real Estate & Mgt. Co. 2013 NY Slip Op 50745(U) Decided on May 8, 2013
Supreme Court, Queens County Kitzes, J. we see a typical issue. What happens when the system spins, and the owner is…
Sometimes It’s Just Too Late to Start That Case
Plaintiff’s mother brought a personal injury case against the City of New York for plaintiff from an injury of December 20, 2002. She retained defendant attorneys to represent her. She discharged the attorneys via a "Consent to Change Attorneys" in August , 2006. She brought the legal malpractice caseFleyshman v Suckle & Schlesinger, PLLC …
It’s a Three Year Statute of Limitation, No Matter What You Call It
Some years ago the Legislature overruled the Court of Appeals, and passed CPLR 214(6). That statute was interpreted to say that all claims against an attorney (some other professionals) were subject to a 3 year statute, whether the claim was made in negligence or contract.
Here, in Walter v Castrataro 2012 NY Slip Op 02676…
Legal Malpractice as an Unexplained Pain in the Neck
When clients depend upon the expertise of an attorney, and then end up with a bad result, they can successfully plead legal malpractice. Does a client settle the personal injury case or litigate on? Depending on how the attorney advises the client, there may or may not be legal malpractice. Here is an example.
Polanco …
Failures to Appear and Legal Malpractice
Reading the background information or the caption of some legal malpractice cases often reveals issues about the case itself. In Stuart v Robert L. Folks & Assoc., LLP 2013 NY Slip Op 03319
Decided on May 8, 2013 Appellate Division, Second Department , we saw that the defense counsel’s name was all alone in…
What The Plaintiff Could Not Prove in this Legal Malpractice Case
While the decision inZaidman v Marcel Weisman, LLC 2013 NY Slip Op 03323 Decided on May 8, 2013 Appellate Division, Second Department does not specifically set forth what Plaintiff could not prove, we believe it would have been "notice" of a defective condition, and lack of proof (in the alternative) of creation of the…
Do Police Officers Have Legal Malpractice Rights?
The short answer to the question is yes, they do; the longer answer to the question is that their rights to first amendment protection of speech is very limited, and litigation over those rights will be stringently examined, or better put, subject to strict scrutiny. In Ruotolo v Mussman & Northey
2012 NY Slip Op…
Carrier Now on the Hook in a Legal Malpractice Case
Legal Malpractice insurance companies have two big exclusions. One is late notice of a claim and the other is acts outside the policy coverage. Late notice is a constant danger to the insured. Carriers take the position that as soon as the attorney knows there has been a mistake he is obligated to tell the…
An Early and Unsuccessful Motion for Summary Judgment in a Legal Malpractice Case
We believe the legal malpractice case based upon an unsuccessful medical malpractice case is among the most difficult cases of any to litigate. The practitioner must understand medical malpractice as well as legal malpractice, an in Vitale v Meiselman 2013 NY Slip Op 30910(U)
April 25, 2013 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: 108969/12 Judge:…