It’s popularly thought that legal malpractice is all about the mistakes made by an attorney. While that is the first elements of legal malpractice, there are far harder hurdles to jump in a successful case. Mistakes, or problems in the way a case was handled are not that difficult to fine, attorneys being human, and
Legal Malpractice News
Still a 6 year Statute of Limitations in a Near-Legal Malpractice Case?
For those with any knowledge of the history of the statute of limitations in legal malpractice, there was once a time in which a three year s/l for tort and a six year s/l for contract existed. Under the Court of Appeals in Santulli it was permissible. In response the Legislature passed CPLR 214-6:
" an…
How Close is the Relationship in Legal Malpractice?
In Denenberg v Rosen ;2010 NY Slip Op 00081 ;Decided on January 7, 2010 ;Appellate Division, ;First Department ; Moskowitz, J. the question of when the relationship begins between client and attorney is discussed. Plaintiff, who was a knowledgeable investor, as a commodities trader, formed a retirement account that was ultimately disallowed by the…
One of the Larger Legal Malpractice Cases in NY is Dismissed
We have written that legal malpractice cases arise from a large base of underlying matters. Here is a huge NY case that starts in Austria, travels east to Russia, and then is dismissed in New York. In this story from the NYLJ by Nate Raymond we see how an Austrian Bank which lost it all…
Another Example of the Collateral Estoppel Trap in Legal Malpractice
We’ve discussed the oft-found fact situation of how a fee determination by a bankruptcy court may block a later legal malpractice action. In Breslin Realty Dev. Corp. v Shaw ; 2010 NY Slip Op 00087 Decided on January 5, 2010; Appellate Division, Second Department; Chambers, J., J. the court writes persuasively about the concept:
…
Criminal Legal Malpractice in the Federal Arena
Criminal defendants have a well known and exacting path. Arrest, Indictment, Trial, Appeal, CPL 440 Motion (or its federal equivalent) habeas proceedings, and finally, they often turn to a legal malpractice action. In New York there is a strict prohibition against suing ones criminal defense attorney. Its sort of a quasi-immune situation. "New York law also…
Settlements, Bankruptcy Court and Legal Malpractice
Continuing the trend towards a combination of bankruptcy and legal malpractice, we note that bankruptcy follows, and rarely precedes legal malpractice situations, hence, we expect a swell of the intersection following the financial down-trends of the past year. Here, Tabner v Drake
2009 NY Slip Op 10006; Decided on December 31, 2009 ; Appellate Division, Third…
The Long Road to Plaintiff’s Partial Summary Judgment
Plaintiff suffers a construction accident, and his attorneys wait too long to bring the action. He had a Labor Law 200.240, 241 and other claims, typical in a gravity-fall construction case. His attorney admit that they waited too long to commence the action, but was successful in dismissal of the Labor la 200 and 240…
Is Negligent Referal Just a Variant of Legal Malpractice?
In today’s NYLJ, Abraham B. Krieger writes a compelling article about "negligent referral ", and gives some history and out of state cases, along with a discussion of NY cases in the area. To backtrack, Mr. Krieger writes: "Recently, New York’s Appellate Divisions in the First, Second and Third departments, and a number of other…
The Fourth Department, Legal Malpractice and Bankruptcy
In Dischiavi v Calli ;2009 NY Slip Op 09773 ;Decided on December 30, 2009 ;Appellate Division, Fourth Department we see a discussion of the effects of a bankruptcy filing on a legal malpractice claim. While the governing principal applies to any cause of action which a plaintiff had when bankruptcy was filed. it seems…