Privity of contract is an essential in legal malpractice litigation.  One may not sue the opponent’s attorney; only one’s own.  What makes for privity of contract?  As all know, no writing is necessary to create a contract.  So, can there be privity of contract without a retainer agreement.  Putting aside Rule 137 questions about the…

So often, the practice of law seems to have devolved into an attorney v. client battle over the work and fees.  Here in Morelli & Gold  LLP v. Altman, NY Slip Op 31492(U) we see a large scale battle over a child support/custody case in which there has been litigation, fees, fee dispute, trial de novo…

Legal Malpractice litigation is a world apart from the rest of regular litigation ; it has its own rules, it has its own prinicipals, and is the sole set of rules written by attorneys to regulate attorneys.  Criminal legal malpractice is a world within a world…not unlike a russian doll set.

Here, in a Federal District…

Attorneys deal in areas of well settled law and in areas of "unsettled law."  Clients have problems or issues which exist, no matter how settled the law is in that area.  Attorneys are held to a standard of reasonable care in all aspects of their representation.  How does one square these contradictory settings?

An answer…

In Weksler v Kane Kessler, P.C. ;2009 NY Slip Op 04957 ;Decided on June 16, 2009 ;Appellate Division, First Department  we see the fatal duo of lack of privity and lack of proximity.  The short story is that Plaintiff, while married to decedent was promised a life-long annuity of $ 4000 per month, said to…

The short answer is when there is spoliation.  Spoliation is the intentional or negligent destruction of evidence.  It may take place prior to, or during litigation, and it always deprives one side of the use of otherwise admissible evidence. 

In the helicopter case, it seems to have been intentional. IN RE HELICOPTER CRASH NEAR WENDLE …

We have commented about the Collateral Estoppel trap in legal malpractice with regard to fee arbitrations and hearings.  in short, when a court grants an attorney fee application, it implicitly determines that there can have been no malpractice, as the court may not award fees in the face of malpractice.  Fee arbitrations and hearings in…

Clients often ask whether it matters that their legal malpractice case comes as a defense to an attorney fee case.  It should not, but judges are swayed by the procedural setting of cases before them.  Does it make a difference whether the legal malpractice case is a main action or a counterclaim?  Taking a look…