In an unusual turn of events, defendant moved to amend his answer and for summary judgment. His motion was denied, and he took an appeal. In an unusual timing situation, trial and verdict in the case , Borges v Placeres 2012 NY Slip Op 51883(U) Decided on October 3, 2012 Appellate Term, First Department favor
Legal Malpractice News
When Attorneys Defend Themselves
"An attorney who defends himself has a fool for a client" appears to date from 1809 in the Philadelphia the Port Folio. Nothing has changed over the past 200 years. In Guerrera v Zysk
2012 NY Slip Op 06578 Decided on October 3, 2012 Appellate Division, Second Department we see an example. Defendant attorney appears pro-se. …
Out of Money, Jailed and Now…Losing a Legal Malpractice Case
How many fathers go to jail for non-payment of child support? We have no firm number, but guess it is less than 10 a year in New York State. Here is the story of one who was. Joel Amaker was in arrears on his child support, and hired defendant Howard D. Lee to represent him. …
Experts in Legal Malpractice
Experts (we might as well call then wizards) are an essential part of litigation, and in legal malpractice litigation they are everywhere. What are the rules, what are the uses, and when are they essential? In answer to these questions, we’re excited to share an Outside Counsel column from today’s New York Law Journal, entitled…
A Sad Story from Landlord Tenant Court
Cases in Landlord-Tenant court often have sad back-stories, and even sadder endings. InAlves v 152-154 W. 131st St. Holding Co., Inc. ;2011 NY Slip Op 32328(U) ;August 25, 2011
Supreme Court, New York ounty ;Docket Number: 116783/10 ;Judge: Donna M. Mills we see only the begining of a tale so complex, that it does…
Are Legal Malpractice Cases Often Wrongfully Dismissed?
We’ve asked in the past whether there is an institutional bias against legal malpractice cases. Self-regulation of industries ( the LIBOR, for example) often lacks any rigor. The legal world also, in a way, self regulates. It is after all, rules for attorneys, written by attorneys, administered and judged by attorneys. In Wiener v Epstein …
Jewelery and a World of Malpractice Trouble
Legal Malpractice cases arise everywhere, and in so many circumstances, In Manus v Flamm , 2011 NY Slip Op 31691(U); Supreme Court, New York County; Docket Number: 110026/2007; Judge: Debra A. James tells an interesting story of divorce, legal malpractice and itinerant jewelery. Plaintiff is the divorced wife, who is owed $ 1 million in the…
The “French Person” Defense in Legal Malpractice
In an otherwise garden or varietal attorney fee dispute with a legal malpractice defense, we ran across the "French Person" defense to attorney fees for the first time. Justice Gische, in Singer v Adler ; 2010 NY Slip Op 33439(U); Sup Ct, NY County gave it short shrift.
"This action is based upon claims for…
Successive Attorneys and Privilege
Client retains Attorney 1 who is said to commit legal malpractice, and then retains Attorney 2 to try to help fix the problem, and later, to sue Attorney 1. What communications between client and Attorney 2 are privileged. in Roberts v Corwin 2012 NY Slip Op 32403(U) September 10, 2012
Supreme Court, New York County  …
In the Intersection between Legal and Medical Malpractice
A potential client comes to the legal malpractice practitioner and says that a good medical malpractice case was lost at trial because of errors by their attorney. They tell you that their expert was precluded, and that the case was lost against all defendants. What’s more, the defendants were permitted to ask hypothetical questions that…