This would be the place for a witty take-off on an American Express ad, playing off the "Don’t leave home without…"  This however, is a story of how a foreclosure case started, went to judgment, and then unraveled.  Attorneys are found to have violated professional standards, and American Express has no attorney in the fight. 

In American Express,  v. Charles Nath, Defendant, 22507/07 ;Civil Court, Richmond County
Judge Philip S. Straniere writes:

"Plaintiff, American Express, commenced this action against the defendant, Charles Nath, alleging that the defendant owed for charges incurred on his credit card. Defendant defaulted in appearing and answering and on January 24, 2008 a default judgment was entered against the defendant in favor of American Express in the amount of $11,794.01 which included interest, costs and disbursements. Plaintiff was represented by Mel Harris & Associates, LLC in this litigation.

As the defendant did not have an attorney, the case appeared on the trial calendar for self-represented individuals initially on January 26, 2010. It was adjourned to May 4, 2010, October 5, 2010 and then to February 8, 2011. On February 8, 2011, counsel for Mel Harris & Associates, LLC appeared and informed the court that they were no longer counsel for the plaintiff. As a result of that, the court on the second call of the calendar, dismissed the plaintiff’s action and issued an order vacating the default and permanently lifting any stays and restraining notices previously served on his bank accounts or garnishments served upon his employer.

A review of this file revealed several substantial problems. First, there is no record

*2

of an assignment of the judgment from American Express to LR Credit 14,LLC. If no such assignment had been made and the clerk made an error in the caption, then why was there no attempt by anyone on behalf of the plaintiff to correct the court file? Discussion with the parties at the bench leads to the conclusion that American Express is the proper plaintiff and the parties were proceeding with that as the fact. An order was subsequently issued directing the clerk to correct the paperwork in the file to eliminate LR Credit 14, LLC as the plaintiff.

Second, no matter which is the correct entity to be designated as plaintiff, Mel Harris & Associates, LLC, is listed as the attorney of record. There is nothing in the file to indicate that Mel Harris is no longer counsel. If that law firm has been relieved as attorney of record, some notice should have been given to the court and to the defendant. Although it is a common practice in the consumer debt industry to sell delinquent accounts faster than George Steinbrenner would send a rookie pitcher back to the minors after one bad outing, no such right exists for attorneys.