The 183 day rule in NYS taxation bobs to the surface from time to time. In this accounting malpractice case, where plaintiff resided makes a difference of about $1 million in tax. Client relied upon the CPAs explanation of how the 183 day rule is applied, to his detriment. Was that advice the [or a]
Legal Malpractice News
One Motion Succeeds, One Fails in a Legal Malpractice Case
Summonses and Complaints served at the very last minute are a study in tension and worry. With good reason, practitioners should fear the NY rules on service of pleadings. Has the process server found a person of discretion? Is in hand service good enough for the case? Has the after-mailing been performed correctly? Sometimes, it is not…
Professional Negligence and Bernie Madoff
It seems that everyone was in on the Barnie Madoff delusion, including Unions in Upstate New York. How the IBEW got involved with Madoff is not stated. However, they lost enough money to sue their CPAs. In Board of Trustees of Ibew Local 43 v D’Arcangelo & Co., LLP
2015 NY Slip Op 00113 Decided…
In Pari Delicto and Professional Negligence
A client is free to sue his professional, whether it be an attorney, an accountant or even a doctor. But, if the client has "dirty hands" or has participated in some untoward act, he may be blocked from pursuing the case. This is the principal of "in pari delicto."
In an accounting setting, Schwartz v …
Heartbreak in the Subtext of a Legal Malpractice Case
The legal principals are straightforward, and the prose is cool and scholarly, but the subtext to this legal malpractice case is heartbreaking. Parent against child; economic interests tearing apart families.
Take a look at Cusimano v Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, Edelman & Dicker LLP 2014 NY Slip Op 04428 [118 AD3d 542] June 17, 2014  …
No Legal Malpractice In This Estate Matter
Plaintiff lacked two elements of a successful legal malpractice case. The two missing elements were the "but for" aspect which requires that "but for" the mistake of the attorney there would have been a better outcome for the estate. The second missing element was ascertainable damages. Here, the estate had to prove that there would…
Settlement Negotiations Immune from Judiciary Law 487 Application
Judiciary Law 487 is the ancient attorney deceit law. It arose just years after the Magna Carta. During the period between 1267 and today, attorneys have constantly been negotiating cases for their clients. Here, in Wailes v Tel Networks USA, LLC 2014 NY Slip Op 02861 [116 AD3d 625]
April 24, 2014 Appellate Division…
Morphing of a Medical Malpractice Case into a Legal Malpractice Case
There are a lot of law firms that take on medical malpractice cases. In the past, medical malpractice litigation was more lucrative than it is today. At one time, attorneys were permitted a 33.3% fee. Now, it is on a lower sliding scale. At one time physicians were willing to testify at trial for a…
A Legal Malpractice Case Lost; It Was Too Soon
Legal malpractice cases sometimes face a conundrum. The three year statute of limitations is approaching, yet the case is not finished. Attorney 1 (the potential target) is out, and Attorney 2 is continuing the case. What does the careful plaintiff do?
One solution (which requires the court agree) is to start the case and then…
Legal Malpractice and Decedent’s Estate
Privity in legal malpractice law is one of the major stumbling blocks. People definitely suffer from the acts of attorneys, yet may not be in a direct contractual relationship with the attiring. Executors and estates are one prime example, and in the past (before Schneider v. Finmann) had almost no ability to sue the…