Often, a losing criminal defense attorney will. because they are usually really sympathetic guys, go to bat for a client by allowing the client to ‘give them up." This usually comes up at an ineffective counsel application by the defendant. Here is a prime example:
"A defense attorney tried a different argument for why his convicted client should be given a new murder trial: the attorney was too sleepy.
Charles R. Curbo wrote in a motion for a new trial that he could not properly represent the defendant, Tony Wolfe, because he was tired during the six-day trial in January.
"The court constantly rushed defense counsel, who the court knew had little sleep on account of the hours that the court was keeping for no good reason," Curbo wrote.
But Assistant District Attorney General David Zak, who prosecuted the case, said he saw no lack of enthusiasm from the defense.
"I saw no change in legal ability from Monday to Saturday," Zak said. "The defense attorney showed anger, passion and zeal in representing his client. There was never a moment when he was running out of gas."
Wolfe was convicted of first-degree murder for shooting 27-year-old Leondus Hawkins in September 2004 at a service station parking lot. He was sentenced to life in prison.
But both sides said the trial held long and late hours due to the defendant’s medical condition and because the judge wanted to send the sequestered jury home as quickly as possible.
Wolfe required dialysis treatments every other morning and kept the trial from starting until early afternoon for some days. The proceedings went on until 10 or 11 p.m. on some days.
"My client is already worn out from dialysis and they make him stay up there until 11 at night and he can’t remember his name hardly," Curbo said.