Justice Judith Gische of Supreme Court, New York County presents a primer on attorney fee litigation and the disposition of counterclaims for legal malpractice in Hurley v. Bulah Church of God in Christ Jesus, Inc. In this case the Church had gone through some hard times. A pastor was accused of financial wrongdoing, and the Church was in Bankruptcy Court for taxes and other debts. Attorney was retained, and worked on the case in what turns out to be an admirable fashion. When the Bankruptcy was winding up, leadership of the Church changed, and he was no longer so admired there. Effect? The Bankruptcy court approved fees, and he was paid. Nevertheless, there were post-discharge work and fees, and this dispute in state court followed.

Read for the excellent description of why and how an attorney is due fees. "an attorney who is discharged by a client for cause has no right to compensation or a retaining lien, notwithstanding a specific retainer agreement. Teichner by Teichner v. W & J Holsteins, Inc., 64 NY2d 977 (1985). On this motion plaintiff has successfully established that he: 1) owed unpaid legal fees; 2) was not discharged for cause, but withdraw as counsel with court approval; 3) deposited money into his attorney escrow account to be applied to post closing matters, like distribution of money to creditors, etc; and 4) Deacon Roberts was authorized to attend to the church’s financial matters with respect to the reorganization. Thus, plaintiff has proved he is owed unpaid legal fees and other fees."